"You're going to have to take a lot more risks before this is over. If it ever is. Once you've been labeled a traitor, you can't just turn back. Do you understand that?"
"I do," Matner nodded. "And I know I will always wish I could have explained this to my parents before they end up hearing it from someone else. But that's not enough to deter me. Part of the reason I left was to find my own path, not have my parents to determine it for me."
"Hmm," Arnish said, looking thoughtful for a moment. "And this isn't, perhaps, about the girl?"
"The girl?" Matner asked, confused.
"You wouldn't be the first young man to fall for a young Elven woman, Matner. I've been down to see for myself. She's quite attractive."
"I - I..." Matner found himself caught off guard by the shift in conversation. He knew he did have an attraction to Sharnellynn, but also knew he wanted to protect both her and her son. And he'd known when he'd seen the rest of the elves caged in the dungeon, that he couldn't just leave them behind.
"No, sir," he answered emphatically. "This isn't just about her. As I said before, I want to get all of them out of there."
"Well, what do you two think?" Arnish asked, casting glances at Loridan and Miraselle.
"There have been plans laid before, to try and save people from the dungeon, but never carried out," Miraselle said softly from behind him. "Part of the problem was often having no one to defend them while they travel west. Smuggling out one or two with the occasional caravan has been one thing -"
"Miraselle!" Loridan erupted, clearly upset. "You say too much before this boy with a sword. Even if we can trust him, do you really believe he could defend them and find somewhere safely out of the King's reach?"
"I can't just stand by and watch another Elven child die, Loridan. I can't. We know Chrisella well. If we have a way to save her daughter... What would we do if it were our child?"
There was a silence that blanketed the room for a moment, thick and heavy. Arnish was staring at the empty fireplace, his brow furrowed. The darkness was enough that he couldn't see the expression on Loridan's face clearly enough to read it, and Miraselle was still behind the chair Matner sat in.
"Perhaps Chrisella should have taught Gyra better than to try and escape. Perhaps we should all learn. Perhaps the Gods intend this as our fate." Loridan's voice sounded tired and sad.
"You shame your heritage with those words, Loridan," Miraselle said, somehow gently despite the accusation the words held, " and mine."
Loridan seemed to be looking at her, and Matner found himself holding his breath as he waited for one of them to speak.
"There will be cost," Loridan finally said. "Is it worth it?"
"I think it's time. I think it's long overdue."
"Very well."
Loridan's words were barely a whisper, and he turned away, going back to dusting the bookshelves. Miraselle stepped around the chair and looked straight at Matner. Her eyes were filled with determination, the gentleness he'd seen before momentarily missing.
"I hope you are truely prepared to do what's necessary," she told him. "People will die for what we are about to do."